Refrigeration contractors have been warned to be aware of the risks of uneven wear and burn-out on multi-compressor packs.
Green Point, the compressor remanufacturing and service support arm of BITZER, says the problem occurs on packs with relatively simple control systems whose default run sequence results in extended running hours for certain compressors, while other units remain underused or even idle for extended periods.
Will Pribyl, Green Point UK general manager, said: “On many multi-compressor packs, a small number of compressors often end up doing much of the work due to the run sequencing control and load profile. This is obviously not ideal and invites trouble. Add to this the problem of compressor cycling on secondary units, and it is an all-too familiar cause of breakdown, with all the consequent costs of downtime and product loss. We see this often in our remanufacturing operations, however it is almost entirely avoidable through planned rotation of compressors.
“It is a lot less expensive to rotate compressors, removing worn units and remanufacturing and replacing them on a planned basis, rather than waiting for the pack to break down and having to replace the failed unit in an emergency.”
To address the problem, Green Point is introducing a planned compressor rotation service for multi-compressor packs as part of its support for contractors, ensuring plant remains operational and continues to perform efficiently throughout its lifetime.
The approach is aimed particularly at business critical areas such as data centre cooling, the food and drink industry, and high value process applications such as pharmaceuticals and the chemical, oil and gas industries.
“The ideal rotation interval will depend on the operating conditions and running hours for the pack. However, we can advise contractors so they can in turn formulate a sensible rotation programme for their end user customer,” said Will Pribyl.
“As the work is planned, we make sure all necessary replacement components are in stock, so turn-around is as fast as possible, usually just a couple of days. However, as the outgoing compressor is removed on site, a like-for-like replacement is immediately installed, so downtime is minimised and system capacity remains unaffected.”
The company recently completed a compressor rotation project through distributor RSL Ireland involving two packs, each with four semi-hermetic screw compressors, serving a blast-freezer in a fish processing facility. One of the lead compressors had failed, prompting an investigation which showed that disproportionate run-time was the cause.
Paul Lynch, RSL Ireland technical manager, said: “The packs had been converted from R404A to R409A a year earlier, but that was not the reason for the failure. The breakdown was due to the pack control disproportionately loading the lead compressor. Green Point was able to supply an immediate exchange compressor to replace the damaged unit, and carry out a follow-up compressor rotation project to avoid similar failures in future.”