Why Scotland's rivers could hold key to low carbon future

7414e640-3c6a-46e2-aeb3-e0bd4da04737

20 May 2021
|
The River Clyde means Glasgow has the greatest capacity to offset its carbon footprint
New independent research by greenspace scotland reveals how the rivers flowing through Scotland’s towns and cities and the green spaces between buildings can act as vital low carbon heat sources to help to achieve climate targets.

New independent research by greenspace scotland reveals how the rivers flowing through Scotland’s towns and cities and the green spaces between buildings can act as vital low carbon heat sources to help to achieve climate targets.

The Green Heat in Greenspaces study shows that through the use of heat pump technologies, urban rivers and green spaces can act as major low carbon heat generators with the potential to supply nearly 80 per cent (41 TWh) of the heat demand from Scotland’s towns and cities, saving 4.7 million tonnes CO2e. That is the carbon saving equivalent of taking 1.7 million cars (or 60% of Scotland’s car fleet) off the road for a year.

Julie Procter, chief executive of greenspace scotland, said: “Wind turbines are now a familiar sight producing clean, green electricity. Scotland has an enviable track record in shifting to renewable sources of electricity. However, we remain bottom of the European league table for renewable heat with just 7 per cent of our heat demand being met from low carbon sources. The Green Heat in Greenspaces study shows that Scotland has huge natural reserves of heat locked up in its water bodies and under its greenspaces yet we have barely scratched the surface in terms of their utilisation.”

Around half of all the energy used is for heating buildings, creating a fifth (21 per cent) of Scotland’s greenhouse gas emissions, the majority of which is from burning natural gas supplied by the mains grid. The International Energy Agency (IEA) has recently recommended that to meet our climate goals no new fossil fuel boilers should be sold from 2025. The Scottish Government has been exploring options to reduce depedency on burning fossil fuels for heat. Its recent draft Heat in Buildings Strategy indicates that by 2030 Scotland needs to move one million homes and 50,000 non-domestic buildings off the mains gas grid alongside converting 167,000 buildings that are currently off the mains gas grid to greener sources of heat.

Heat pumps are seen as the primary technology for meeting this challenge. The technology is tried-and-tested and in widespread use in countries like Sweden, Norway and Austria. Heat pumps are able to extract some of the sun’s heat from air, water or the ground and concentrate it through a process that compresses refrigerant gases into a small volume. In this way small increases in temperature can be used to boost the heat of water significantly before transferring the heat to a single building or, alternatively, to hundreds of buildings. The latter requires a system of inter-connected, sub-surface water pipes known as a district heat network. Larger scale projects are best located close to existing hotspots of high heat demand like our town and city centres to minimise the costs of laying underground pipes. 

The properties of water make it a far more effective medium for storing and releasing heat than air. River catchment areas act as giant solar heat collectors concentrating water-borne thermal energy into their river channels. As these ‘heat highways’ pass through urban centres, heat pumps located within energy centres on the banks of rivers are able to extract heat from the river water through submerged pipes. In Scotland the best example is the recently operational scheme at Queens Quay in West Dunbartonshire where heat is being extracted from the River Clyde and delivered to a wide range of new buildings on the site of what was once the John Brown Shipyard.

National findings indicate that up to 50 per cent of current heat demand from Scotland’s 516 urban settlements could potentially be delivered from rivers, with significantly higher percentages for some towns and cities.  While cities like Perth, Aberdeen, Stirling and Inverness are all ideal candidates for major river based heat schemes, it is Glasgow that, in absolute terms, offers the greatest capacity to offset its carbon footprint. The heat demand of Greater Glasgow is one fifth of the total demand from all of Scotland’s settlements. As the host city for the 2021 UN Climate Conference, COP26, it can lead the way in demonstrating the huge potential of river source heat for Scotland and the UK. 

Councillor Anna Richardson, city convener for sustainability & carbon reduction at Glasgow City Council, said: “We been heavily involved as a partner in the Green Heat in Greenspace programme to explore how our green and blue spaces could be used to support renewable energy opportunities. We recognise the huge, untapped potential to utilise these assets to address our climate and energy challenges without having a negative impact on current users. Glasgow owes much of its industrial pre-eminence to its location on the Clyde and it is a resource that keeps on giving. As the world’s attention focuses on Glasgow for COP26 over the coming months, innovative low-carbon heat solutions like this demonstrate how the city can address its 21st Century challenges.”

Content continues after advertisements

The city of Perth, with its ambition to become the most sustainable small city in Europe, also offers major potential to utilise the River Tay for its heat supply. The heat capacity of the Tay is many times greater than the annual heat demand from the homes and businesses of Perth. If this ‘spare capacity’ could be utilised then Perth could, at least from a heat perspective, offer the enviable appeal of being able to grow sustainably.

Across Europe cities are looking to implement large scale communal heating solutions using renewable resources such as water bodies, the ground under open space, waste water in sewer systems and even flooded mines. All of these options are likely to be part of the solution depending on the local situation. Yet the true potential of these resources in Scotland has, in many cases, still to be quantified and further research is needed for them to be accurately assessed. The Scottish Government is hoping that local authorities can play a major role in this area through the development of new local energy plans to highlight new zones within our urban areas that offer the strongest opportunities for low carbon heat solutions.

John Maslen, ParkPower programme manager at Greenspace Scotland, said:  “A key aim of this project was to quantify the potential of larger scale heat pump solutions utilising ground source and water source heat. The project has, for the first time, highlighted the true scale of contribution that Scotland’s green and blue spaces can make towards our low carbon heat transition. These are critical low carbon heat assets that need to be incorporated into strategic energy masterplans.

“The study’s outputs will help our public sector partners to measure the scale of the opportunity for every settlement in Scotland. We would like to see policy move towards a more strategic view of how to migrate whole towns and cities towards a lower carbon heat supply. If we are to realise Scotland’s ambitious targets for low carbon heat and net zero, we need to be thinking and working at scale. We need comprehensive national and local energy masterplans that define a clear pathway for Scotland to achieve its low carbon heat targets giving businesses and investors the long-term confidence to support this vision.”

Helen Melone, senior policy manager at Scottish Renewables, said: "While it isn’t yet mainstream in the UK to think of rivers and green spaces as places which can provide the energy we need to keep warm, other countries are further ahead. If we are to have any chance of meeting our climate change targets, the days of burning fuel to produce heat must largely come to an end.

"This new report shows one of the paths we need to follow if we’re to decarbonise heat – a sector which makes up half of the energy we use in Scotland.

"Its findings are important especially in light of the new Heat Networks (Scotland) Act, which was passed earlier this year. Devices like water source heat pumps will be a crucial part of the mix needed to fulfil its, and our, ambitions for heat in Scotland as we move past COP26 toward our net-zero target."

Greenspace Scotland