Trevor Dann, director at ThermOzone explains
In 2008, they upgraded four Carrier chillers, retrofitting the original piston compressors to screw compressors. And, they removed R22 in favour of direct replacement R422D, and updating the controls.
That upgrade achieved ~35% energy savings, and has provided so far 8 years reliable life extension to chillers originally installed in 1988. The latest upgrade has improved efficiency by a further 33% by retrofitting to Inverters and R134a.
Piston compressors on higher temperature applications are anyway very inefficient compared with the equivalent capacity screw compressor, and this accounted for the 35% achieved in 2008 when we converted to Screw compressors.
More recently effective speed control of larger, high torque motors driving screw compressors has become an everyday reality. The key advantage is the slide valve can be held at 100% swept volume, with load variation achieved by simply varying operating speed.
Applying an Inverter to a screw compressor can improve operating efficiency between 15 - 25%, according to the local conditions and load demand.
R134a v R22 / R407C
However, R134a offers some key advantages for these chillers, with one notable disadvantage:
- R134a is ~8% more energy efficient than R407C across the typical load range
- R134a operates at a substantially lower pressures, this is a particular advantage for older equipment because older vessels are placed under less stress.
- R134a is the lowest HFC for GWP CO2 tonnes rating, and established HFO refrigerants and blends are already commercially available
- The key disadvantage for R134a is its lower cooling capacity at the compressor ~30%, and to a lesser extend the evaporator ~ 10%.
Inverters can overspeed
Slower Screw compressor bonus
Net Energy Improvement
For most UK systems the ambient conditions experienced mean many chillers can attain lower load efficiency improvements above 20% for most of the year, with just a few weeks of day time running where the efficiency reduces.
Payback for these projects is typically 2-3 years, and has been recognised Nationally by the Carbon Trust as an effective means to improve equipment efficiency. Some buildings we have worked in have achieved overall rating improvements of 2 levels, e.g. G to E, or F to D.
When this is balanced against prior improvements of ~35% the overall efficiency reduction from Piston with R22 / R407C (or equivalent), final overall improvement can be ~55-60%. At one site we have audited results showing low load improvements with R134a and Inverters of 72%, with Summer time improvements of 55%.
Any savings that can be applied to the compressor can achieve substantial improvements for the clients.